President Donald Trump signed a presidential memorandum on Tuesday that would exclude undocumented immigrants from being counted in congressional districts when district lines are redrawn next year.
The memorandum marks the Trump administration’s latest effort to change the way US populations are
counted and advance the President’s immigration agenda. And like previous efforts, the issue will end
up in court.
“I have accordingly determined that respect for the law and protection of the integrity of the democratic
process warrant the exclusion of illegal aliens from the apportionment base, to the extent feasible and to
the maximum extent of the President’s discretion under the law,” the order states.
The American Civil Liberties Union plans to challenge the memo, Dale Ho, director of the ACLU’s Voting
Rights Project, said in a statement.
“(Trump’s) latest attempt to weaponize the census for an attack on immigrant communities will be found
unconstitutional. We’ll see him in court, and win, again,” Ho said.
Trump has long sought to use the US census as a way to advance his immigration priorities but the
Supreme Court rejected an attempt to ask respondents if they are US citizens in 2019. The
administration, however, is allowed to collect information on citizenship status by other means.
And like the attempt to add the question onto the census, the memorandum marks yet another effort
that would likely impact the balance of power in states and the House of Representatives, which are
based on total population.
The memo comes as the 2020 US census is still taking place. So far, Census.gov reports 62.2% of the
country has responded to the census, which has been going on for months.
Convincing immigrant communities to participate in the census has already been an uphill battle, and
Trump’s announcement threatens to deepen fears in communities where some were already wary of
Community organizations and immigrant advocacy groups across the country have spent months
focused on outreach efforts to convince immigrants to participate in the census, regardless of their
immigration status. Even though no citizenship question is on this year’s census, advocates worried
lingering fears over the question would deter immigrants from responding and lead to shortfalls in
funding for schools, roads and other community projects.
But on Tuesday, advocacy groups that have devoted resources to boosting census participation said
they were ready to fight the administration’s latest effort to influence the count.
“The Trump administration’s action today is even more clearly unconstitutional, as they seek not just
to chill participation from noncitizens, but literally to remove them from the final numbers,” immigrant
advocacy group CASA said in a statement. “CASA will again fight this in court and ensure that everyone
is counted in the 2020 Census.”
The courts will likely have the final say. The Constitution says congressional representation is
apportioned based on “the whole Number of free Persons,” not only those who are American citizens.
“The legal problem is that the 14th Amendment says that representatives shall be apportioned among
the several states according to their respective numbers, counting the whole number of persons,” said
Joshua Geltzer of the Georgetown University Law Center.
“That means House seats are divvied up based on everyone present in the 50 states, not just based on
those lawfully present,” he said.
In addition, Geltzer said, the census doesn’t currently ask whether someone immigrated illegally to the
United States. “Presumably the Trump administration will have to rely on a hodgepodge of other records
to guess the population they intend to use for apportionment.”
Michael Li, who serves as senior counsel for the Brennan Center’s Democracy Program, questioned
how the federal government would make the determination on whether someone is undocumented.
“The Constitution requires counting everyone — children, immigrants, everyone — it doesn’t have
exclusions based on legal status,” Li said.( CNN / IM )